ALTUĞ BERKER:Master you said; "What lies at the root of elder brothers who are Nur students hiding the subject of Hazrat Mahdi (pbuh) is their attempt to prevent making young people unsettled. Saying; "What if Hazrat Mahdi (pbuh) do not emerge, what if Hazrat Mahdi (pbuh) dies, then would there be a shock of faith in young people?".. That is the reason why they are trying to cover up the system of the Mahdi, Allah knows the truth. They might be thinking that there would be disorder. In order to prevent people getting apprehensive and feel troubled thinking "Is he going to emerge? What if he does not appear? Would he be successful, if he does? What if they martyr him as soon as he comes out?" they adopt an attitude to cover up these facts. Otherwise, twelve of the twelve elder brothers know that Hazrat Mahdi (pbuh) is a person. They tell this during their private conversations. They do these with good intentions, but people need to be careful about those done with bad intentions."

ADNAN OKTAR: Yes.. Now, since Hazrat Mahdi (pbuh) is a person, for example they say "he might have a heart attack and die any moment" or "he might die of cerebral bleeding or that someone might shoot him." They think that the faith of all people would be shocked in such case. However, when our Prophet (saas) came, Muslims believed that he was a Prophet and they trusted in him. It was certain that he would be the Prophet till the end and that he will bring the Book. So no one ever could do anything. He lived till the age of 63 and he was martyred with his honor and the Messenger of Allah (saas) went to Sight of Allah. Because he died while struggling in the Path of Allah and he passed away while he was preaching the religion. According to this fear, according to this logic, Islam would never prevail throughout the world, once people start to think with this mindset. So saying that it is a "collective personality"; they would destroy the collective personality you claim as well. If what they mean are the students of Nur, disbelief could gather and destroy all of them. If you are evaluating in terms of the strength of unbelievers, they could gather all the students of Nur in the world. So there is no such thing that they could not achieve that. They could find them by searching house by house and street by street. They could gather all of them if they want. Just like it happened during the Second World War? Right? For example, let us say Jews; they have gathered all Jews one by one and house by house and they massacred all of them. Or for example this happened to the Romans as well. There were Roman people and they gathered all of them one by one by detecting them all one by one and massacred them. Therefore, they think that collective personality is invincible.  One cannot harm the collective personality but the collective personality cannot do anything either. No one can do anything to the collective personality and the collective personality cannot do anything to anyone either. But the collective personality would bring about division, would break up the society and nothing else..